Plot: A continuation of the horror anthology told as a series of kamishibai productions.
Breakdown: When I first went into the fourth season of Yami Shibai 4, I was met with a tidal wave of negative comments and reviews. People hated this season with a passion, but I was more than open to it because, well, I really love this franchise. While they have had their share of bad stories, I wasn’t ready to write off this season from the start.
That being said, this season is, by far, the weakest of the seasons so far. Each season has had their problems. Season one was the strongest, though was damaged by the stupid toilet monster story. Season two had plenty of good ideas, but ultimately ended up a largely ‘meh’ season with poor execution. Season three relied a bit too heavily on monsters for my taste and changed into a format that was slightly difficult to get used to, though ultimately paid off very well.
Season four didn’t do anything different except made the narrator tell the whole story, which has its ups and downs, and include one live-action shot per story, which is largely pointless. It had many silly or meh stories and ended with absolutely no fanfare.
Episode 1: Tongue – 5/10 Clever-ish twist, but confusing to the point where I can’t make much sense of it at all. It’s also not that creepy or scary.
Episode 2: Fish Tank – 2/10 Not scary, creepy or clever. It has the most cliché of all horror story plots and only kinda gets points for using a monster that I’ve never seen done before.
Episode 3: Sewing Shears – 3/10 Again, not scary and very cliché. Points only go to the kinda creepy monster and the aspect of shears.
Episode 4: Red High Heel – 5/10 Good idea, nice start, poor execution. Disappointing. I still think my suggested ending would’ve been better.
Episode 5: Night Bus – 7/10 Best episode so far, but still not very strong.
Episode 6: Guess Who? – 7.5/10 Getting better. This one is creepy, off-putting and clever, but the only thing that gets me is the logistics of what exactly happened and who that girl even was.
Episode 7: Footsteps – 5/10 Middle of the road rating for a middle of the road entry. I should dock it off for reminding me of the toilet episode, but I feel nice today.
Episode 8: Cassette Tape – 8/10 I really enjoyed this episode, and it’s impressive that it gets a rating so high given that there is really not much animation on screen. It’s mostly just the shots of the tape recorder. Creepy, amps up the tension very well and uses its concept very well. I just wish the box had been better explained.
Episode 9: Grinding Teeth – 6/10 Creepy focal point, cringey (in a good way) sound effects, not too bad about halfway in, drops the ball and falls flat. Disappointing.
Episode 10: Calling Crane – 9/10 My favorite of the entire season. While the game itself is just weird, this is a very beautifully drawn and colored episode with plenty of creepiness and atmosphere.
Episode 11: White Line – 8/10 Clever and creepy with a unique enough premise and freaky visuals. A lack of live-action shot is distracting due to the break in continuity, though.
Episode 12: Snow Hut – 6.5/10 I still can’t decide on how much I really like this episode. It’s clever, but not scary. It has some creepy visuals, but it makes me sadder than anything else. Plus, it really bothers me that they never explain why this snow hut needs someone occupying it.
Episode 13: Underground Walkway – 6/10 You ever have those moments where you’re watching a horror movie and you want to yell out to the screen ‘Don’t go in there! Who the hell would go in there?! Turn around! Does this look safe!? Go back! You ran into a scary person! Turn around! What is wrong with you?!’ That is this episode in a nutshell. I docked off half a point because this is the season finale and it fizzles out. Is it the worst entry? No. But it does require major stupidity to pull the plot off and the twist isn’t that scary at all. Being a disappointing season finale, especially when you’re following up the awesome season three finale, is just not cool.
Overall Rating: 6/10
Recommended Audience: No worse off than any other Yami Shibai season. 10+