Space-Time Detective Genshi-Kun/Flint the Time Detective Episode 17 (16 for the Dub) Sub/Dub Comparison | Fly! Fly! Wing!

Plot: In America 1881, the young Wright Brothers meet the flying Space-Time Monster, Wing, who can give anyone and anything the ability to fly. Orville in particular grows attached to Wing after getting fed up with the way Wilbur treats him. Tokio, also feeling annoyed by how Sora treats him, sides with Orville and Wing, flying off with them in protest of their older siblings.

—————————————–

Starting today, we have new title card art in the original. Instead of showing Genshi, we now show a bunch of Space-Time Monsters.

Title Change: Fly! Fly! Wing! is simply changed to Wing.

They add an establishing shot of the town before the establishing shot of the lab.

The original just says that Sora is older than Tokio. The dub specifies that Sarah is 327 seconds older than Tony.

Sora points out that Tokio blundered in his homework because she’s told him before to do the equations in the parentheses first but he didn’t do that. In the dub, Sarah says “When will you learn to multiply before you divide?” Uhh….

When we see him typing, he’s writing the numbers on the bottom fraction, which I think means he’s showing his work, but it doesn’t make any sense that this is the way the way the homework…works. And this is coming from someone severely math dumb.

Either way, he hasn’t multiplied or divided yet. He’s just writing out the way he thinks the fraction should be simplified, which isn’t correct, but still. If your criticisms of his work are also incorrect, you’re not helping anyone.

I’m going to see if I do this equation just to make sure I’m not too math dumb.

The simplified version should be 6+1 ½, which would be 7 ½…..right? Did I do it? Are ya proud of me?

Genshi asks Ototan if it’s really that bad having siblings. Oto-tan says it’s just because they’re so close. In the dub, Flint asks Rocky why he doesn’t have a sister. Rocky says it’s because cave sisters eat their brothers for breakfast….Uh….huh?

Tokio just wishes he were the older brother, presumably so he’d be the one with the edge instead of Sora. In the dub, he says his homework would be a cinch if he were the older one…….How?

They insert a shot of the Masked Man after the closeup shot of Wing in the montage.

I’m shocked beyond belief that they got this next info correct. The Wright Brothers moved around a lot when they were kids, so the fact that anime writers knew to look up exactly where they were in 1881 (Richmond, Indiana) is commendable.

Also, Masked Man just says he and TP Lady can have a sky date if they capture Wing. In the dub, he says they could fly up and have a date on the moon. Yeah…..pretty sure just growing wings wouldn’t allow you to fly up to or survive in space, but you do you.

Orville says to Wing after Wilbur tells him to come down “Listen to him, Wing!” In the dub, he clunkily explains who Wilbur is to Wing and subsequently the audience.

Name Plate Removed:

Subbed:

Dubbed:

Orville yells down to Wilbur that Wing will get lonely if he comes down, so he’s staying in the air. In the dub, Wing, who can talk because it’s the dub, asks Orville what Wilbur’s problem is. Orville says Wilbur is jealous because he wants to fly more than anything, and he’s flying around in the air but Wilbur can’t.

Wilbur originally tells them to quit messing around and come down otherwise he’ll get angry. Orville refuses, mocks him and flies off with Wing. In the dub, Wilbur says, “Those wings aren’t flight-worthy!”…..Uh….they’re flying…..so…..yes they are. Also, he’s flying without flapping his wings most of the time and is able to hover perfectly still in the air without flapping as well, so they seem more than flight-worthy to me….they seem like budgetary restraints on animation.

While it took them until adulthood to develop a serious interest in aeronautics, the Wright brothers did have a love of aeronautics at a young age. When they were children, Orville seven years old and Wilbur eleven, their father bought them a model helicopter made of bamboo, paper and cork that they loved playing with until it broke. While they couldn’t really do much with their interest until later on, they did claim this toy was what first inspired them to get into aviation.

They buckled down and took a serious interest in flight engineering in 1896, when Orville was 25 and Wilbur was 29. This was when there was a huge boom in people experimenting in aeronautics. The death of Otto Lilienthal, a German aviation engineer, was cited by the Wright brothers as being the biggest turning point in their interest in aviation. Lilienthal had been testing a glider, but it crashed, causing him to break his neck. He tragically died the next day.

Orville: “They’re more flight-worthy than anything we’ve made so far! Just watch, brother!”

They haven’t made or attempted to make any actual flying machines at this point in their lives, but they did make a toy helicopter similar to the one they had that broke. It didn’t fly, of course, but it’s still cool that they made one.

The art and animation in this episode is noticeably worse than normal. Every shot just looks really bad. Did they cut their already paltry budget?

They extend Petra’s dialogue by reversing the shot of her pointing her finger at Orville and Wing.

In the original, Sora says Tokio better not be too reckless. In the dub, she says “This oughta be good for a laugh.”

*snort* That dumb vacant expression Wilbur has as the camera just holds on him being still for several seconds is gold. I really must reiterate – this episode looks AWFUL.

Tokio says Orville and Wing have been playing too many pranks, and it was mean to do all that stuff to the town. In the dub, he yells “I don’t know who you are, but Wing’s coming back with me!” Yeah, the best way you can convince the Time Shifter that you’re on their side is by demanding that they have no other choice but to go with you….

Orville originally asserts that he wasn’t playing pranks with Wing, he was performing research. In the dub, he oddly responds to Tony’s demands by saying “Take your hands off of me! I’m an inventor!”

That’d be like me saying “Take your hands off of me! I’m a blogger!” Like, who cares? Why is that a reason to let you go?

They repeat shots of Orville and Tokio talking to extend the scene.

Orville: “That’s right, a famous inventor!” No, you’re not. At least not right now.

In both versions of the flashback, Wing flies by saying “Wing!” but it’s already been established in the dub that he can speak English, so it just sounds like he’s saying his name for no reason.

In regards to Orville and Wilbur having any sort of sibling rivalry……….that’s a bit hard to say. They did have arguments, they didn’t agree on everything, but they seemed to get along much better than most siblings. They grew up together, shared everything, talked a lot, worked together, brainstormed together, played together, shared their toys, worked most of the same jobs in the same businesses, and they never really had much in the ways of issues.

I’m not saying this plotline of them having a sibling rivalry is unlikely, every pair of siblings has their moments of clashing no matter how close they are, but, from all I’ve read, I can’t imagine Wilbur would treat Orville like he was stupid and had no idea what he was doing.

Original!Orville: “Just because my brother’s grades are a little better in school, he always acts like I’m stupid!” This is actually true, barring the end part.

While there’s nothing to imply Orville ever did badly in school, he was quite bright and curious after all, he never seemed interested in pursuing higher education. He dropped out of high school and never had plans to go to college.

Wilbur excelled in school and he had high aspirations for his scholastic future, not only planning on finishing high school and going on to college, but choosing Yale as his college of choice. It was only after he badly injured his face in a hockey game as a teen that he abandoned those plans. He had lost his front teeth and suffered other injuries that left him in a lasting and deep depression. He, like his brother would, dropped out of high school and abandoned his plans for college, choosing to stay home, read and care for his ailing mother.

Again, though, I doubt Wilbur ever treated Orville like he was stupid because of whatever difference in their grades may have been.

The art is killing me. Tokio is just staring over Orville’s head as he talks to him.

By the way, I’m not going to discuss all of the controversy in regards to whether the Wright Brothers were really the first to invent the airplane. By all intents and purposes, and simplified as much as possible, they did. We can “Well, technically” and “But what about” until the cows come home, but in the end I feel confident in saying that they were the first. As much as I love doing research on random topics for these reviews, I really don’t feel like combing through hundreds of pages of articles debating this topic, especially since most of the articles I did read still ended up with conclusions stating the same thing, which is “We may never know for absolute certain who invented the airplane first, but the general consensus and evidence we have still support the Wright Brothers.” If you, personally, have a different view, that’s fine, I won’t fight you on it, this isn’t a hill I want to die on, just know that, in regards to criticizing and legitimizing the history covered in this episode, we are going to take them inventing the airplane as gospel.

Speaking of being technically correct, they ignore the fact that Wilbur and Orville were actually two of seven children. Orville and Wilbur had two older brothers, Reuchlin and Lorin, and one younger sister, Katharine. They also had twin siblings, Otis and Ida, but, sadly, they died when they were infants. They didn’t need to bring them up, and there was really no organic way to do it anyway, I just wanted explain that they’re not the only Wright siblings. I’m particularly disappointed that we won’t be able to discuss Katharine because she was a huge supporter of her brothers throughout their engineering of the airplane and helped them with building and testing. She wasn’t officially an engineer, but she was definitely mechanically inclined, and she was a key player in the woman’s suffrage movement in Ohio. She’s a very interesting person, but I understand why she’s not here. Not only are there the time constraints and difficulty in fitting her into the story to consider, but Katharine would only be about seven at this point, so she’s not really doing much besides being a typical little girl.

Orville originally says Tokio and him are brothers now. Tokio’s the older brother, Orville’s the middle and Wing is the little brother. In the dub, it’s the same, but instead of calling them brothers he calls them all expert flyers.

I love how Orville and Tokio’s big plan to get back at their older siblings and teach them to respect their little brothers was to mock them and then leave. That’s literally it. The entire plan. They went back to ‘protest’ their older siblings, bii-daa’d them, left, dicked around for few hours and then said ‘Well, I’m sure they’ve learned their lesson now.’

Tony: “Boy, I’m afraid our plans have started to backfire.” Boy, I’m afraid your dialogue has started to seem really awkward.

I love how the dub is also including propeller sounds when Tony, Orville and Wing are flying by when they’re clearly flying with regular wings and should be accompanied by wing flap sounds.

They change the animation of TP Lady whipping Wing to one that lasts a little longer and involves her waving it around a little more…..*shrug*

Name Plate Removed:

Subbed:

Dubbed:

Name Change: Waruwing is changed to Wing-kon.

Orville originally just exclaimed that Wing transformed. In the dub…

Orville: “This will have Wilbur shakin’ in his boots!” Orville, read the room.

Being fair, though, it doesn’t take long for original Orville to join him in being a little sociopath.

Waruwing attacks Ridon, sending Genshi, Sora and Wilbur hurdling through the air, and Orville responds by smiling and happily yelling that that will teach Wilbur a lesson.

Hey, guys, you want to hear a not-so-fun fact? Orville was the pilot on the first ever fatal airplane crash. On September 17, 1908, he took part in a flying demonstration on the Wright Military Flyer when the blade of a propeller split and hit a bracing wire, causing the propeller to shatter, the bracing wire to break free and the rudder to swivel to a horizontal position, causing the plane to veer out of control and nosedive into the ground. As a result, 26-year-old Lieutenant Thomas Selfridge was jettisoned into a wooden upright, causing a severe skull fracture which would prove fatal in mere hours. Orville had a fractured femur, four fractured ribs and a hip fractures that would continue to affect him for the rest of his life, though he did recover enough to work just fine.

What I’m trying to say is, Orville, flying is really dangerous, and your brother can’t learn any lessons if he’s a big red stain on the ground. So maybe not cheer when a living fighter plane crashes into him as he’s perched precariously on the backseat of a flying robot dinosaur bike above the clouds.

Also, if I can’t imagine Wilbur treating Orville like a useless idiot no matter what age they are, I certainly can’t imagine real-life Orville being giddy at his brother being in mortal danger.

Dub!Orville: “I want him to scare my brother so much he turns bright green!”…..Wh…how would that happen?

Waruwing’s little black wing dart things don’t have a name in the original. In the dub, they’re called Petra Darts.

Original!Orville: “Stop it! Brother is going to get hurt!” Oh NOW you care.

Dub!Orville: “Please, Wing! I didn’t mean it! I was just kidding!” No, you weren’t, you liar.

Orville originally calls out to Wing, but in the dub he tells Tony and Flint (I think) to get out of Wing’s way.

Rocky: *getting grabbed by Petra’s ship’s giant hand* “It’s a handasaurus!” Rocky, goddammit.

Hahaha, that shot of Orville falling right before Waruwing catches him. My god. It’s literally just a single oddly drawn unmoving frame of Orville straight on while the background moves. Wow.

TP Lady says her face is all muddy now. Dyna and Mite tell her she’s beautiful even with a muddy face. She should flap her wings and head to the sky like an angel…..I really don’t see how that makes sense other than they’re referencing the fact that they’re flying away right now.

Petra says she’s sick of being thwarted by Flint and his friends, she’s getting crazed with anger, and she won’t let them humiliate her again. Dino and Mite then say she should have worn her seatbelt, but it’s a good thing they did, Petra puts on her seatbelt before they fly off and leave. Sooo…Petra made a big declaration acting like she was about to attack again, then leaves?

Wilbur: “We decided from now on for the both of us to come up with ideas and make the airplane together.”

Aw that’s nice.

*Orville immediately produces a model biplane* Where the actual hell did you get that?! In the few minutes between TP Lady leaving and now how did you somehow build a wooden plane that perfectly exemplifies your combined ideas in a design that surpasses concepts that shouldn’t exist for like 20 more years? That doesn’t even look like the Wright Flyer, it looks like a more advanced biplane.

Tokio says things are better when siblings get along. Sora says with a pointed look “You say that now….” And Tokio gets a nervous/goofy expression on his face. In the dub, Tony’s responding to Wilbur talking about the ‘aeroplane’ and says “Yeah, that’ll be great. You can bet on it. Right, Sora?”

And then Sora says with her expression of suspicion “How about it, bro? Are we friends?” And Tony responds with the weird expression “Yeah.”

If they forgot everything involving the kids and Wing…..doesn’t that technically mean that Orville and Wilbur would just forget that they made up?

Old Timer: “If those two brothers hadn’t learned to get along, we’d still be traveling by horse and buggy.” No, no you wouldn’t. First of all, the automobile will be invented five years from this point. Second of all, I guess let’s just bop this topic one more time, many other people were testing with flying machines when the Wright Brothers had invented the airplane to the point where there were a ton of legal issues and controversy to this day about who actually invented the airplane first. If not them, you can rest assured the airplane would be invented, tested and patented in roughly the same amount of time. Who knows how different the world of aviation would be, but we’d definitely have airplanes.

Also, Sora and Tokio go back to fighting because they love each other so much and nothing was learned.

I wasn’t expecting the two to be best friends or anything, and I was definitely expecting the status quo to be restored by the next episode, but we’re literally exactly where we started. Sarah pestering Tokio about how he’s doing his homework wrong, him getting upset and Ototan explaining that they fight because they’re so close, which is a bit of a toxic mindset. My sister used to insult me and get into fights with me all the time, and I never once felt like it was because she cared about me.

Actually, let’s dissect this further. If a big sibling yells at you for being reckless or getting in trouble or something, then yeah, it’s reasonable to believe that they just love you and don’t want to see you get hurt. As children/teenagers themselves, they might not know how to protect you from these things without losing their temper or treating you like a little kid. But when it comes to acting like you’re stupid, being condescending and just overall being an ass, that’s not caring or love, that’s just, well, being an ass.

This episode was entirely Orville and Tokio getting treated badly by their older siblings and them having to learn a lesson while Wilbur and Sora just kinda went back to what they were doing. Wilbur seemed to have grown, but Sora clearly hasn’t. She didn’t even lend Tokio a kind word about how brave he was to tackle Waruwing so they could get a chance to escape or how heroic he was in catching Genshi when he fell. She just complains that he’s not understanding her explanations of his homework again.

Flint: “Oh yeah? Well, if that’s really true, I wanna get in on the fight!” See how weird that sounds?

You can really tell how much they were banking on this show being a hit because, after the credits, my copy of the episode keeps these little commercials for the CD of the soundtrack for the show, including the single of the ED performed by Manabi Mizuno, who was so proud of her work on the show that it’s not even listed on her IMDB page. Manabi Mizuno did go off to become a fairly successful singer and voice actress for several anime with a career spanning nearly two decades.

——————————————–

Overall, despite some issues and TERRIBLE art and animation for whatever reason, this was a pretty good episode. Sora and Tokio butting heads has been a recurring enough issue for this plot to be engaging, and having Orville and Wilbur Wright act as their sibling rivalry counterparts was a decent enough choice, even if they really didn’t seem to have issues of that caliber at any point as far as I know.

Wing is a pretty cute Space-Time Monster with an interesting power, and his bad transformation is really cool. It not only has a really interesting design, being a vertical fighter plane with a vulture-like face, but it has two pretty intimidating attacks in a propeller that detaches and launches at his opponents, and two machine guns that shoot razor sharp feather darts.

The aerial battles were some of the best fighting scenes the show has had to offer so far. Being in the air changes the game quite a bit and makes it more exciting considering that, without Ridon, Genshi can’t fly. And he may be durable, but not even he couldn’t survive a fall from like 30,000 feet.

History-wise, there were some questionable things, but they actually got most things right…..or…should I say WRIGHT? Hahahahahahaha…..hah…..*cough*

Most of the stuff I went on about was just either built on conjecture, slight nitpicking or just things I found interesting that I wanted an excuse to share. The worst of it was the very ending where Orville magically produces a perfect biplane replica out of thin air after the battle with TP Lady. How? How? How?

Being fair, considering how they’ve been lately about this stuff, it’s much better than I ever feared. At least they didn’t have Wing build the plane for them and then they forget Wing and take credit for inventing it or something. And the stuff Orville learned from Wing was stuff that is very much akin to things Orville and Wilbur were researching in real life during adulthood. They studied birds and their wing shapes to help them design the wings of their future planes, creating the concept of “wing warping” which would help stabilize the plane in flight and allow for better control.

In the show, Orville learned about flying from watching Wing, who is technically a bird, and observing how everything else flew when Wing gave them the ability to fly with those bird wings. Of course, he couldn’t really learn much from that considering Wing’s powers seem more magic than realistic. I mean, they fly with their wings perfectly still, tiny wings could flip TP Lady’s ship, etc. but this is another moment where I’m just being a bit nitpicky.

If there’s one thing I’m very hung up on about this whole story is….they’ve been trying to build the world’s first airplane….They have a Space-Time Monster who can make anything fly, they’re battling a woman who has a flying cat-shaped spaceship and they’re befriending people who have a flying dinosaur bicycle. Why are they not more amazed by this stuff? Why are they not asking more questions? Why are they not taking notes on how these things work?

Next time, TP Lady takes control of Ammon, putting Kyoichiro in danger.

….Previous Episode


If you enjoy my work and would like to help support my blog, please consider donating at my Ko-Fi page. Thank you! ♥

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Space-Time Detective Genshi-kun/Flint the Time Detective | Episode 11: Get Fired Up! Nekketsu Sub/Dub Comparison

STDGKEP11SCREEN1

Plot: Genshi, Sora and Tokio head to America in 1906 where the Space-Time Monster, Nekketsu, has befriended an 11-year-old George Herman Ruth, known later as the legendary baseball player, Babe Ruth.

—————————————

They add in a stock shot of Ms. Jinguuji talking between when the kids enter the building and when they pan across the room.

Name Change: Nekketsu is changed to Batterball

The original doesn’t state that Nekketsu has the power to instill people with great athletic prowess like the dub does. All he does is control any type of ball and create balls.

There’s no excuse for this change. In the original, Genshi hears “batter” and mistakes it for the word “butter” and gets excited. In the dub, he hears clearly but thinks they’re talking about batter for pancakes. Granted, the joke here isn’t better or worse than the one in the original, but there was no reason to change it.

Title Change: Get Fired Up! Nekketsu is changed to Batterball

The original just says they’re heading to 20th century America. In the dub, they specifically say 1906. I don’t know why the dub is consistently more accurate on the year than the original is, but give Saban their props. When the original keeps saying (#)th century, it’s way too vague. Technically, this episode was made in the 20th century, for crying out loud, and 1906 is just barely on the cusp of the 20th century.

As usual, the dub chooses to show the kids getting on Ridon up on the second floor and descending down to the transport bay while the original hasn’t shown that in a while.

Nekketsu’s name plate is removed.

Subbed: STDGKEP11SCREEN2

Dubbed: STDGKEP11SCREEN3

Originally, George asks Genshi if he’s okay. In the dub, they make him an idiot by making him ask if Flint’s an asteroid.

Apparently, Saban transformed the shoes of those bullies who were kicking Batterball into clown shoes because they add horn honking sound effects whenever they stomp on Batterball.

I think this has happened enough now to add this note.

Entire Series Edit: In the original, the Space-Time Monsters can’t talk. They just say their names or make random sounds, like Pokemon. In the dub, they can seemingly all speak English fluently.

In the original, Genshi introduces himself as a friend and then proceeds to dance around while singing his ‘Friends’ song. In the dub, Flint says he’s there to protect George and Batterball. George asks what a small kid like him can do, and Flint just…..dances to the chanting from the theme song for some reason.

George wonders if Genshi even understands what he’s talking about. In the dub, he says Flint probably takes a lot of vitamins. Fun fact: vitamins were discovered by Casimir Funk who coined the term “vitamins” (originally ‘vitamines’) in 1912, a full six years after this episode takes place. I honestly just checked that for the hell of it, thinking vitamins were way older and this joke worked, but nope.

Sora tries to remind Genshi that playing baseball is not what they came here to do. In the dub, Sarah says giving Flint a mitt will keep the ball out of his mouth….??

Tokio then says it’s not fair for Genshi to catch and that he should have a shot at bat…….Dude, he literally just caught ONE ball. George literally batted ONCE. You’re saying that arrangement is unfair? In the dub, Tony suggests letting Flint take a few swings while they look for a mitt. That’s better, admittedly, but George has a mitt. We just saw it a second ago.

Putera says that’s not what Sora was talking about, and Sora laments that even Tokio’s not focused on work anymore. In the dub, Pterry says he bets Flint can hit, and Sarah says she hopes Flint doesn’t mistake the bat for a French fry. Ahahahah, and all, but they do realize that Flint’s a caveman…..bats are basically just thinner clubs.

What’s with these baseballs, by the way? They have no stitching. Were actual baseballs really expensive back then or did the animators just not put them on for some reason?

Sooooooooooooooo…..Tokio’s all like ‘This isn’t fair!’ when Genshi is made the catcher ONCE, but Genshi using his stone hammer as a baseball bat, that’s perfectly fine?

Dub!George: “No way he’s going to hit my curve.” I know jack shit about baseball and even I can tell that pitch wasn’t a curveball. It just kinda swayed back and forth.

Yes, George did cheat by using Nekketsu/Batterball, but, again, it’s also cheating that Genshi/Flint used his massive stone hammer when batting….

Pterry: “Boys will be boys.” I friggin’ hate that saying.

Getalong: “But why?”

Sarah: “Why? Because I think boys are ridiculous and juvenile.” Ah the common casual sexism in children. One of many things in the ‘Problematic yet generally overlooked’ bucket.

……..Also, Sarah, that does not answer Getalong’s question at all.

Sora originally said that she doesn’t understand why boys get so heated over stuff like this, which is still sexist but not nearly to the extent Sarah was being.

I love how TP Lady/Petra Fina, Dyna/Dino and Mite are all super happy with themselves for pulling off their plan of grabbing Nekketsu/Batterball while everyone was distracted, even pointing out that that was, specifically, their plan……when…ya know….they could’ve just made off with Nekketsu scot-free if they just left the kids to their personal squabbles instead of drawing attention to the fact that they were stealing the Space-Time Monster/Time Shifter….

The Masked Man originally suggests making doubles with him in real life. In the dub, he tells Petra that her serve is almost as beautiful as she is.

Oh god, the original actually plays the ‘Wahh wahh’ horn when TP Lady gives in to the taunting and agrees to the game when she said the taunting wouldn’t work. Give the dub credit, they didn’t mirror that music cue….

Putera and Love-Love originally pretend they’re the announcers for the game. In the dub, Pterry explains that, per the rules of the game, Petra’s team pitches first since they’re the visiting team (aren’t they all technically visiting, though? Barring George.)

Honestly, this IS is a stupid idea considering TP Lady has control over Nekketsu…the Space-Time Monster who controls balls….

They flip the shot of Tokio hopping around to get the ball and repeat it after Petra starts running.

When the scene returns to normal play, they also flip the shot of Sora running after the ball for some reason.

It’s really weird that George is blaming Genshi/Flint for getting hit with the ball. It’s obvious Nekketsu did that.

They mirror the shot of Flint running through the wall, I guess to make it not as obvious that they reused that shot in the original……Who the hell keeps putting random walls on the field?

Still running commentary, Putera asks Love-Love about her opinions on the game. Since Love-Love can’t talk, she just mutters her name over and over. In the dub, Pterry asks Getalong what they should do. Getalong says “Who cares? It’s just a game of baseball.” Uh….yeah….it’s a game of baseball where the lives of one of your fellow Time Shifters hangs on the outcome…..Pterry points this out, but since when is Getalong such a jerk?

Right before showing George getting emotional, they insert a shot of Pterry talking into the camera to Petra Fina, for some reason, apologizing for Flint and Tony’s catch……???

Sora says it feels like everyone’s been best friends for a long time. Sarah tells the others that they have a game to play.

Alright, if just using Ototan as a bat isn’t against the rules, surely using Fighting Spirit when at bat is. Again, TP Lady’s team is cheating too, so it doesn’t matter, but I’m still a little hungup on Tokio’s comment from earlier.

Name Change: Reiketsu is changed to Batterball-kon

Name plate removed.

Subbed: STDGKEP11SCREEN4

Dubbed: STDGKEP11SCREEN5

Reiketsu seems to only be able to say “Unbelievable” and grumbles in English. In the dub, he can still speak full fluent English.

They repeat a shot of Batterball-kon juggling Flint and Rocky before George yells at him.

Wow, George sounds way too old when he says “Batterball, put ‘em down!”

They repeat the closer shot of Flint and Rocky being juggled before Petra laughs.

Merlock: “Hello, Pretty Sarah.” Hello, Creepy Merlock.

Did….did Kyoichiro’s legs seriously give out from under him and cause him to roll down the hill?…..Why? Because…he was flustered by Sora? What?

They change the shot of Flint talking to George to a repeat shot of him talking from a few seconds before.

They insert the shot they cut in order to place that repeat shot in there to right after George starts to rear up for his hit. Such purposeful edits today.

TP Lady angrily lamented that she’d never be able to make doubles with the Masked Man now. In the dub, she comments that they won by being nice and she hates nice more than anything.

They extend the scene of Petra, Dino and Mite leaving by showing them in the time stream and showing Petra yanking on Dino and Mite’s heads.

They remove a short scene with Toki-G explaining everything. Old Timer says the same dialogue in narration, though.

STDGKEP11SCREEN6STDGKEP11SCREEN7

Another instance of a day shot being swapped for a sunset shot. This makes even less sense because the shot immediately following this one takes place outside where it’s clearly day again….

The original more or less implies that Nekketsu is depressed because he had to leave George. In the dub, they claim it’s because he hasn’t been able to play baseball since he arrived in the 25th century.

In the original, since I guess we didn’t have enough story to fill the full 20 minutes, they add a new segment called Toki-G’s Space-Time Monster Course where Toki-G explains the specifics on some of the Space-Time Monsters discovered so far. In the dub, they make up an entirely new segment that’s not so much a proper segment (Where Sarah would be acting as a host speaking directly to us) and instead cuts to a scene where Sarah is updating her ‘Flint File’ which hasn’t been mentioned until now, and she basically does the exact same thing, only she goes over more Time Shifters and forms than Toki-G did.

The segment also continues on with Tony telling Sarah to come along since they’re taking Batterball to a baseball game. She refuses because they have too much homework. They fight, just like in the episode from which these clips are taken, but at the very last second they makeup and say they’ll do what the other wants.

————————————–

So that was……an episode.

What a dreadfully boring episode, to be honest. I might be slightly biased because I already find baseball to be a snorefest (although, fun fact, I wrote a paper on Babe Ruth when I was in middle school. I had to dress up like a baseball player to deliver it too. Don’t remember why, but there it is.) but, seriously, there is NOTHING to this episode besides the gimmick of baseball. NOTHING. It’s the same song and dance we’ve seen nearly a dozen times already without any substance to it.

At least they didn’t pull a Rodin and imply that Babe Ruth got his athletic ability from a Space-Time Monster, but outside of hitting Baseball!Genshi, George didn’t do anything of note. He hit one good home run, which Genshi caught in his teeth after jumping up about six stories, and then he cheated after he took a turn pitching by using Nekketsu to manipulate the ball so he could make an impossible catch. George didn’t come off as an unlikable kid, but he wasn’t that likable and did nothing impressive. The ‘emotional’ parts also felt very shoehorned in. He was pretty boring.

Nekketsu is also a weird Space-Time Monster. He controls…..balls? He turns things into balls?….Wow? Impressive? Not to mention that Nekketsu’s voice is very odd. It’s too deep.

Granted, Reiketsu’s a little better. Wielding four spiked clubs and being able to shoot nearly endless amounts of baseballs at high speeds is pretty intimidating. Truth be told, I’ve always wanted to try a batting cage, but I’ve always been worried the machine would go nuts and shoot balls at me. Silly, yes, but leave me alone.

To make matters more boring, we don’t get a new good transformation of one of the Space-Time Monsters today. They don’t even call for backup in this episode.

At least Genshi didn’t get hungry in this episode, but that’s not much consolation.

I didn’t even get to really research anything today, and that just overcooks my noodles.

All I got to research today was vitamins.

VITAMINS.

Based entirely on an off-handed remark.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

VITAMINS!

….Moving on….

Next episode seems a bit strange….We’re introduced to a Space-Time Monster called Ammon, who is hanging out with…..Dracula….so….either he’s hanging around a fictional character and acting as if he’s a historical figure…..OR…..we’re going to be focusing on Vlad the Impaler, the actual inspiration behind Dracula…..who was one of the most cruel mass murderers in history…..Uh huh….I get that there’s a lot of ‘Well, Vlad had a point’ in regards to his leadership and rule, but dude was still bathing in the blood of tens of thousands of people. So, uh, I dunno where this episode will lead us, but we’ll have to wait and find out.

…Previous Episode


If you enjoy my work and would like to help support my blog, please consider donating at my Ko-Fi page. Thank you! ♥

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Space-Time Detective Genshi-Kun/Flint the Time Detective Episode 8: Sphin’s Riddle Sub/Dub Comparison

FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN1

Plot: The Space-Time Monster, Sphin, is in ancient Egypt under TP Lady’s control. She has taken over as queen with a legion of slaves who have been brainwashed by Sphin. He possesses the power to put anyone under mind control if they fail to solve his riddle. Genshi winds up under Sphin’s spell after failing a riddle. Tokio and Sora have been fighting lately, but can they come together to save Genshi and Sphin?

———————————–

Title Change: Sphin’s Riddle is changed to Lynx.

The first shot of the episode was originally a panned still shot of the sphinx in Egypt. In the dub, it’s replaced with an outer shot of the research facility.

Sora was explaining (and basically foreshadowing) how legend states that the sphinx would posit difficult puzzles to wandering travelers, and how the sphinx and pyramids were symbols of the power of the pharaoh. In the dub, Sarah basically just explains what the statue of the sphinx is and that it dates back to over 2500 BC.

Tokio originally just wants Sora to help him with his research paper whereas Tony wants her to copy her own work and give it to him. Yeah I’m so sure the teacher wouldn’t notice that.

Sora tells Tokio that, if he can’t even do his own homework, he’ll never be a Time Detective. In the dub, she tells him that she refuses to cheat.

Then Tokio tells Sora that she’s making too big a deal out of it, since he could do his homework just fine if he wanted. Sora argues that he can’t do anything on his own, and they pout. In the dub, Tony whines that he thought he and Sarah were a team (and thus she should feel obligated to let him cheat?) Sarah argues that they are a team, but being a team means he has to do some work too. Tony argues that he is doing his best, but she’s always hogging the computer. Sarah retorts by saying he’ll never be a Time Detective without her. Uh, yeah, Tony’s argument doesn’t really stand up. 1) He’s not doing his best if he’s not even trying to do his work and is just asking her to cheat for him and 2) she was done with the computer – he could have done his work then.

They splice in a closeup shot of Jillian between when Flint and the others pop up but before she introduces Lynx.

Name Change: Sphin is changed to Lynx.

The original specifies that they’re going to Giza, which the dub omits, but then the dub adds that they’re going to 323 BC, which wasn’t specified in the original – they just said ‘ancient Egypt.’

When they arrive in Egypt, we see a closeup of the sphinx, which has now been altered. In the dub, we get the panning shot of Egypt that was removed before, only this time it’s reversed.

Likewise, Tokio asks what’s up with the sphinx but Tony just says he senses something weird.

TP Lady points out how she altered the sphinx to look….like her I guess? I really don’t get what they did to the sphinx. It does obviously look wrong, but it doesn’t really look like TP Lady.

In the dub, she just goes on about how she’s more beautiful than that ‘hag’ Cleopatra.

Despite the dub not mentioning the changes made to the sphinx, they decide to leave in that TP Lady wants to also put her face on a pyramid (to help the masked dude find her faster) but the way they wrote it is weird. She, again, wants to sleight Cleopatra and says she’s going to carve HER face into a pyramid, acting like Cleopatra either had her face carved into the sphinx and she’s trying to one-up her (I guess, because the sphinx would obviously draw more attention) or she’s trying to copy something Cleopatra did…..both of which are wrong.

The Great Sphinx of Giza is suggested to emulate the face of the pharaoh, Khafre. While this has been debated a few times, I’ve found no theories suggesting Cleopatra was the model for the sphinx head. In fact, she was born way, way, way beyond when the sphinx would have been created (She was born in 69 BC and the sphinx has been estimated to have been created sometime in the 2500’s BC) – and archaeologists have even been debating the age of the sphinx as being much older than originally cited.

There are much smaller sphinx statues, one even depicts female pharaoh, Hatshepsut (For an awesome re-telling of her story, check out Puppet History’s episode on it. It’s a great series as a whole if you like cool stories from history. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rm9t94mpkjo ) but not a one that depicts Cleopatra.

As for carving her face on a pyramid, as far as I can tell, this is also false. She did have a massive carving of her likeness embedded into the side of the Dendera Temple, but that’s about it. There have been tons of art made in her likeness, including statues and busts, but when it came to glorifying her in massive statues and buildings, there’s not much to discuss. Even her and Antony’s tomb has never been found.

Interestingly, in 1998, a small sphinx was discovered underwater that was said to emulate the features of Cleopatra’s father, Ptolemy XII Auletes, but again, nothing directly about Cleopatra.

In the end, I have no idea why they’re so hung up about Cleopatra at the moment in the dub, especially considering they’re a few hundred years behind her birth, but that’s Saban for ya.

They add in a further shot of the scene after Petra points out that the kids are here, and there’s no dialogue so it’s just a really awkward pause for no reason, and they add a closer shot of Petra talking while she summons Lynx.

Sphin’s name plate is removed.

Subbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN2

Dubbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN3

Also, it is frickin’ adorable that Sphin barks.

Sphin’s little asp thing asks “What’s something that you use when you’re not using it and that you don’t use when you’re using it?” In the dub, it asks what’s everyone in the world is doing at the same time.

The answer is a bath plug. In the dub, the answer is that everyone’s getting older at the same time.

Tokio originally just says they should leave. In the dub, he suggests Lynx ask Pterry a riddle. Wow, so you want Pterry to be enslaved too? Nice, Tony.

Tokio originally tells Sora that she should’ve known about Sphin’s power (….How? Rei gave them nothing but vague clues about it.) then Sora accuses him of the same and they argue. In the dub, Tony pretends like he knew all along about its power, but then Sarah calls out his BS and they argue.

I know Petra was saying “All I wanted was a back rub, but I end up getting stomped by a bucking bronco boy!” But I had to double take when she first said that because I would’ve sworn she said “fucking bronco boy.”

Ya know, considering how strong Genshi is overall and the crazy things Genshi tries to eat, Sora’s arm should be either bleeding profusely, broken or both after being bitten like that. He’s even gnawing on her.

Sphin asks “What kind of bird is always a lonely bird?” In the dub, Lynx asks “What can you catch but not throw?”

In the original, the answer is “One person” or “Hitori” since one person is lonely and “tori” is Japanese for “bird.” In the dub, they insert more talking from Lynx between when he asks the riddle and when Sarah answers. Also, the answer in the dub is a cold, because that is one of the easiest riddles in human history.

Next, the original asks “What is something that will always mirror something else?” In the dub it’s “What runs but has no legs?”

The answer in the original is a mirror. In the dub, it’s a nose.

They do keep the next riddle, more or less “What reflects like a mirror, but never shows itself?” the answer is also kept the same – an echo.

Originally, Kyoichiro was silent when he was miming the echo….because….ya know….that’s how miming works. Also, he’s trying to stay silent so he won’t draw attention to himself. In the dub, he’s making noise and talking, which is stupid because he might as well just say ‘Echo’ outright if he’s going to talk.

We don’t see Kyoichiro vanishing in the original like we do in the dub. I’m to assume they just reversed the footage of him appearing.

Tony: “We’re in big trouble if you muck this one up.” Okay, first of all, stop saying things that sound like you want to say fuck but you can’t. Second of all, big trouble how? Lynx is already basically defeated, and Dino and Mite are of no concern.

Sora’s riddle is kept the same.

They add another shot of Dino and Mite talking before Sarah gives the answer.

The answer to the riddle, “What walks on four legs in the morning, two in the afternoon and three in the evening?” is a human, but the dub keeps saying ‘man.’ I get that people can interchange ‘man’ with humanity, but in this context, it sounds like Sarah’s saying only men go through these stages.

The man that Petra was laying on was actually cleaning her ears. In the dub, he says “Peel your own grape.” which is weird because what he’s holding is clearly white and fuzzy, not a grape…unless the grape is moldy or something.

Name Change: Waruphin is changed to Lynx-kon.

Name plate removed.

Subbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN4

Dubbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN5

Does anyone else think Waruphin looks like a sports mascot?

Usually, the abilities of the transformed Space-Time Monster are a more powerful version of the original’s powers, but for some reason Waruphin’s power is to…trap people within itself?

I get that we’re going for a teamwork moral this week, but neither Tokio nor Sora is needed to turn Tanegun from a fossil into its creature form. Ototan can move on his own, and Love-Love was the one who pushed the button.

Ah hey they’ve finally gotten a reinforcement where they don’t immediately bitch about their efforts to help. Good job.

Name Change: Super Tanegun is changed to Bubblegum Master.

Name plate gone.

Subbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN6

Dubbed: FTTDSDCEP8SCREEN7

They shift TP Lady’s tantrum from after Genshi eats to before.

They insert a shot of Pterry talking before Getalong brings the drumstick for some reason.

Also, again with the ‘we need to feed Genshi so he can fight’ thing.

Originally, Sphin makes a pretty cool almost singing-like sound when he uses his sonic beam. In the dub, he just growls and laughs.

They repeat shots of Genshi talking and Shin reacting after he’s saved.

Originally, TP Lady, Dyna and Mite yell out ‘Spinning’ over and over after Super Tanegun shot at them, but that doesn’t make any sense because they’re not spinning. In the dub, they just scream, which actually fixes this problem.

Oh NOW Love-Love remembers he has powers that literally make people get along. Why bring this thing everywhere if you’re only going to sparsely remember it has that power? Why is he even using it now? Sphin is basically back to normal and is becoming friends with Genshi.

Wait…..are Sora and Tokio actually making up right now or are they just under the effects of Love-Love? The one time they remember to use Love-Love and it’s not only pointless, but it also basically forces the conflict resolution. And even this is pointless because they were bound to make up after all of that.

Again, Tokio asks Sora if she’ll help him do his research paper. In the dub, he asks if she’ll do his homework.

The dub adds an establishing shot of the Land of Time and some old repeat shots of Toki-G before we see the continuing shot of everyone dancing.

Toki-G only wishes he could be with Genshi and the others. Old Timer tells a riddle of his own while saying he should visit Egypt again sometime.

So uhm, important question….is anyone going to bring up that they DESTROYED THE GREAT SPHINX OF GIZA?! Its face is gone and most of it crumbled. Even if the TP Lady part was a big stone mask, the face underneath was completely blank…also the crumbling thing. Geez, reminds me of Dinosaur King where they were destroying ancient Egyptian monuments left and right and no one gave a single shit.

Sora was even writing a paper on it before. If it’s destroyed, then is her paper now wrong?

—————————-

Overall, I liked this episode. I love ancient Egypt, and this was a pretty fun plot they had going here…..even if the destruction of the sphinx was quite annoying. I loved Sphin, though more in the original than the dub because he sounds cuter. The aspect of riddles being used as a method of mind control was a neat concept, and it has a very good design, even if its bad transformation form is just weird.

The teamwork part of the story was….admittedly kinda forced. It does make sense for Genshi to be out for a good chunk due to not being smart enough to figure out the answer to the riddle, the kid barely understands words let alone word problems, but he needed to be taken out three times in this episode. Once through mind control, another being trapped in Waruphin’s body and the final one because he was, yet again, hungry. And all to allow Tokio and Sora to take the reigns so they can show that they do need each other.

I was disappointed because I thought we’d finally get some development with Tokio and really understand what he brings to the table as a team member. He’s the one really gunning to be a Space-Time Detective, but as far as I’ve seen he doesn’t really deserve to be anything more than what he is. He’s lazy, he bickers with his sister and he doesn’t have any outwardly useful traits that no one else has.

Sora is clearly the brains of the outfit, and Genshi is the brawn, Putera is more brains on the side of the technical aspects of being a Time Detective, Ototan helps fossilize and de-fossilize Space-Time Monsters and is a usable weapon, Love-Love has a power that would destroy the entire fabric of the series but is poorly utilized, and Tokio’s….what? The helper?

Even though Sora’s role as the brains is definitely highlighted here, what did Tokio do? He helped hold up Ototan, who didn’t need it (he just needed someone to press the button) and he saved Sora from a rock, which was good, but Genshi could have done the same, and Sora was kinda dumb to just stand there waiting to die.

In regards to comparison, this episode didn’t fare that bad. Typical scene swapping fare, name plate removals and some dialogue changes, but nothing too bad.

Overall, still a good episode, but the teamwork aspect could have used more work.

Next time, we head to 19th century Paris where the Space-Time monster, Horurun, possesses the ability to bring drawings to life. I love the concept of bringing drawings to life, so I look forward to this one.

…Previous Episode


If you enjoy my work and would like to help support my blog, please consider donating at my Ko-Fi page. Thank you! ♥

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com